Elevated PSA: A Guide To Men

Prostate Cancer in New York City – 2026

by Alex Shteynshlyuger MD


If you have any questions, to schedule a consultation, please contact us or call/text: 1-646-663-5515.

We have excellent reviews from patients and their partners.  Information for out-of-state and international patients.  Find out our office hours or directions to our office. 

We offer affordable appointment prices with or without insurance.  Same-day virtual video appointments and in-person appointments are available.

Dr. Alex Shteynshlyuger is a fellowship-trained urologic oncologist, a robotically trained surgeon who specializes in all aspects of care for early, advanced, and metastatic prostate cancer. He is a member of the Society for Urologic Oncology and the American Society for Clinical Oncology.


Elevated PSA: How High is High?

It is important to understand that the PSA test, when used for predicting prostate cancer risk, is not a “Yes” or “No” test.

There is no specific cutoff for the PSA test.  Because PSA varies from man to man as a result of age, genetic profile, prostate size, and a number of other variables, the values that are considered elevated are patient-specific.

Prostate Specific antigen

Prostate-Specific antigen

Typically, lower values of PSA are considered to be elevated in younger men, as they are expected to have much lower values than older men.  So in a 45-year-old man, a PSA of 3.5 would be considered elevated, while in a 75-year-old male, a PSA of 3.5 may not be considered elevated.

The complicating issue is what we call the PSA velocity, which is a rate of change in PSA over time.  Increased PSA velocity can be associated with an increased risk for prostate cancer.  As a result, the same 75-year-old male with a PSA of 3.5 may be considered at high risk for prostate cancer if his PSA went up from 2.5 to 3.5 over a period of 1 year.

The biggest challenge when it comes to PSA values is in the range of PSA values under 10.  With PSA values in the range of 10-20, men are increasingly likely to have prostate cancer; men with PSA over 20 are at particularly high risk. Most men with PSA >20 are eventually diagnosed with prostate cancer, often aggressive.

What is PSA?

PSA stands for prostate-specific antigen. It’s a blood test. Prostate-specific antigen (PSA) is a glycoprotein enzyme produced by both prostate epithelial cells and prostate cancer cells and is the most commonly used serum marker for cancer.

Your doctor will look at your PSA results and must consider your age, your race, family history, medications that you are taking, and many other variables to decide whether your PSA is normal or abnormal.

What You Should Know About PSA

Some commonly used medications for enlarged prostate, called 5-alpha-reductase inhibitors, can cause PSA to decrease by about 50%.  This does not decrease the risk of prostate cancer, and the number needs to be doubled in men taking these common medications: Proscar (finasteride), Avodart (dutasteride), Jalyn (dutasteride plus tamsulosin). A man taking Proscar for 6 months with a PSA of 5.6 measured after 6 months has a corrected PSA of 10.2.

PSA levels vary with age. Commonly used normal ranges are as follows:

  • Men below age 50: Normal PSA less than 2.5 ng/mL
  • Men 50 – 59 years: Normal PSA level less than 3.5 ng/mL
  • Men 60 – 69 years: Normal PSA level less than 4.5 ng/mL
  • Men older than 70 years: Normal PSA level less than 6.5 ng/mL

These results may vary between different labs according to different measurements and samples used.

What Other Conditions Can Cause a Rise in PSA?

  • BPH (benign prostatic hyperplasia)
  • UTI (urinary tract infection)
  • Recent prostatic intervention such as a prostate biopsy
  • Recent catheterization or cystoscopy

What are the factors that raise the suspicion of prostate cancer when having an abnormal or Elevated PSA level?

  • Older age
  • Race (prostate cancer has a higher incidence in African-Americans)
  • Presence of urinary symptoms such as hematuria (blood in urine), urinary frequency (wanting to urinate more often even if only a few drops of urine ), urgency (urgent need to urinate), a sensation of incomplete bladder emptying, split urine stream.
  • If you had a PSA test in the past and a subsequent test shows a significant increase even if the value is still in the normal range.
  • If your doctor finds a prostatic lump or nodule during DRE (digital rectal examination)
  • Other risk factors such as a positive family history of prostate cancer or breast cancer

What are the precautions that should be taken before PSA testing:

  • Be sure to tell your doctor about any drugs you are currently on. Some drugs may cause your PSA levels to be falsely low. These include finasteride (Proscar), dutasteride (Avodart), and antiandrogen drugs, such as flutamide, nilutamide, and bicalutamide (Casodex)
  • Be sure to tell your doctor about any anticoagulant therapy you are currently receiving, such as Coumadin and aspirin.
  • Digital rectal examination causes a modest increase in PSA, but it is not clinically important.
  • Prostate biopsy causes an immediate elevation in the serum PSA level, which usually returns to a stable baseline level within three weeks. PSA is usually not performed within a month after a prostate biopsy.
  • Recent ejaculation and sexual intercourse can lead to a mild increase in PSA, which is not clinically important.

What are the controversies about PSA screening?

Since the introduction of PSA screening for prostate cancer in 1997, there have been many controversies regarding elevated PSA levels. Misuse of the test for screening has created unnecessary anxiety and increased costs and has led to the significant overdiagnosis and overtreatment of men.

It is necessary to use a single PSA determination as a baseline and to do a biopsy for those with significant PSA changes over time or for those with clinical manifestations mandating immediate therapy (such as urinary symptoms). PSA should also be used to monitor disease progression or recurrence.

What is a prostate biopsy?

It is a minimally invasive procedure that can be done in a urologist’s office. In this procedure, a special biopsy needle is inserted most commonly through the rectum (TRUS) to remove small pieces of tissue from different zones of the prostate (optimally 12 pieces) and then examined under the microscope in a Pathology lab to rule out the presence of prostate cancer.

When should you undergo a prostate biopsy?

  • PSA level > 4 ng/mL for men over age 60
  • High PSA velocity, which is a significant change in PSA level between 2 consecutive results
  • Presence of prostate lump during DRE in correlation with high PSA level
  • When the PSA level is higher than 50 ng/ mL, it is 98.5% accurate in predicting the presence of prostate cancer.

Are there any risks associated with prostate biopsy?

A prostate biopsy is a minimally invasive procedure if done by an experienced urologist. Patients commonly experience hematuria (blood in urine), mild pelvic pain, and dysuria (difficulty urinating) after the biopsy is done. Infection is one of the serious side effects that can occur after a prostate biopsy, and it can range from mild fever to infection that requires hospitalization.

What are the other tests used in screening for prostate cancer?

Urinary prostate cancer antigen 3 (PCA3)

It is a urinary marker used in predicting the presence of prostate cancer. It offers slightly better predictive power for prostate cancer than PSA, but that is not valuable in an individual patient as the benefit is small.

Prostate Health Index (PHI)

A new PSA isoform called p2PSA was recently identified. The Prostate Health Index (PHI) is a new formula that combines total PSA, free PSA, and p2PSA into a single score that can be used to aid in the diagnosis of prostate cancer. It is equal to (p2PSA/free PSA) × √PSA

PHI significantly improves the prediction of biopsy outcome (whether benign or malignant) over PSA alone. The number of unnecessary biopsies can be reduced by using PHI.

PHI was found to be more accurate than PCA3 for predicting prostate cancer in the initial biopsy and repeated biopsy.

Both Prostate Health Index (PHI) and Prostate Cancer Antigen 3 (PCA3) significantly improve prostate cancer detection at initial biopsy in a total PSA range of 2-10 ng/mL

4KScore Test

This is a new test that was presented at the American Urological Association (AUA) 2014 Annual Scientific Meeting.

The difference between the 4KScore Test and the PHI test discussed earlier is that it combines 3 PSA measurements (total, free, and intact) with another new prostate-specific measurement called human kallikrein 2 (hK2) in an algorithm.

This algorithm also takes into account the patient’s age, DRE, and previous biopsy results.

The advantage of this test is that it can differentiate between pathologically insignificant and aggressive diseases, and thus it reduces unnecessary biopsies.

References:

  • www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
  • NCCN guidelines for Prostate cancer

Did you know? Dr. Shteynshlyuger has performed over 1,000 prostate, penile, and bladder surgeries, including prostate biopsy, prostate removal, penile implants, Urolift, prostate enucleation, correction of Peyronie’s disease, and MRI fusion biopsy.

Where to Get Treatment for Rising PSA in NYC?

At New York Urology Specialists, we offer treatment for men with abnormal PSA and prostate cancer.  Same-day virtual video appointments and in-person appointments are available.

Call/text today: 1-646-663-5515 or make an appointment online.  

We perform procedures such as prostate biopsy, transrectal prostate ultrasound, hydrogel insertion prior to radiation therapy (SpaceOAR), prostate surgery, prostate enucleation for enlarged prostate, and Urolift procedure. We treat prostate cancer, urinary problems, and erection problems and offer comprehensive STD testing for infections. We offer confidential appointments.

Our appointment costs are affordable with or without insurance.  We offer free insurance verification.

Cost of Prostate Cancer Treatment without Insurance

At New York Urology Specialists, we offer affordable treatment for men. Our prices are low for patients without insurance and for those who have high insurance copays, high deductibles, or insurance plans that do not cover treatment costs. 

At New York Urology Specialists, we offer flat-fee ‘all-cost-included’ procedures such as prostate biopsy, hydrogel SpaceOAR insertion, circumcision, no-scalpel vasectomy, testicular implant, vasectomy reversal, hydrocelectomy, varicocelectomy, and many more.  The procedures are performed in our office under local anesthesia or sedation. Men from other states can save thousands of dollars over local hospital fees by coming to New York Urology Specialists for treatment.  Please contact us for current prices and discounts for patients without insurance or with high insurance deductibles.

Cost of Prostate Cancer Treatment and Insurances

Inexpensive Urologist Visit CostAt New York Urology Specialists, we offer affordable treatment for men. Our prices are low for patients without insurance and for those who have high insurance copays, high deductibles, or insurance plans that do not cover treatment costs. 

We accept many health insurance plans.  We would be happy to verify your eligibility and benefits and provide you with detailed information on your health plan’s coverage.  Financing options and credit options are available to help you pay for medical care.

Why Choose New York Urology Specialists for Prostate Cancer Treatment?

  • All treatment is performed by a board-certified urologist experienced in treating men with rising PSA, prostate cancer, enlarged prostate, erectile dysfunction, low testosterone, scrotal and testicular problems, and urinary problems using medical therapy, minimally invasive therapies, lasers, and surgery.  
  • We are one of the few practices in the region to offer a full range of options for the treatment of sexual, urinary, and erection problems in men.
  • We offer treatment options for side effects and complications of prostate cancer treatment, including erectile dysfunction, Peyronie’s disease, urinary problems, frequent urination, and overactive bladder, in our office.  Office procedures avoid the risks, costs, and recovery from general anesthesia.  
  • We offer diagnostic testing in our office, which avoids hospital costs.
  • Extensive experience: Thousands of men have been treated successfully for elevated PSA, prostate cancer, erection problems, and urinary incontinence.
  • Confidential and Understanding Care. We understand that most of our patients desire privacy.  We see patients with a variety of urological problems. Your reason for visiting us is entirely confidential.
  • We are conveniently located within a 30-60 minute commute to men who are seeking treatment for testicular and penile problems, erectile dysfunction, enlarged prostate, urinary problems, and cancer treatment in Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island, Westchester, Long Island, Bronx, and New Jersey.

What do Prostate Cancer Problems Look Like?

You can find pictures of Prostate Cancer, as well as before-and-after treatment images, in our image gallery.

Scheduling Appointments for Prostate Cancer Treatment at New York Urology Specialists


If you have any questions, to schedule a consultation, please contact us or call/text: 1-646-663-5515.

We have excellent reviews from patients and their partners.  Information for out-of-state and international patients.  Find out our office hours or directions to our office. 

We offer affordable appointment prices with or without insurance.  Same-day virtual video appointments and in-person appointments are available.

Dr. Shteynshlyuger, MD, is a board-certified urologist in NYC who specializes in treating men with elevated PSA, prostate cancer, and sexual, testicular, hormonal, and urinary problems.   He has performed hundreds of penile and prostate surgeries, including penile implants, surgery for enlarged prostate, and many other procedures.  


[patient_review_form]

Treatment for Men With Fast Recovery at New York Urology Specialists

Excellence-Urology_Care-banner2At New York Urology Specialists, our urologists are specially trained in the evaluation and treatment of men’s health concerns, including high PSA, abnormal 4Kscore, abnormal prostate MRI, and prostate cancer.  We understand the challenges that sexual and urinary problems create for our patients with prostate cancer, their relationships, and their self-esteem.  We help you find a treatment for penile problems and urinary problems, including erectile dysfunction, that fit your needs, lifestyle, and preferences.

Urologists are doctors specializing in the treatment of men with prostate cancer, urinary, and sexual problems that include penis problems, scrotal problems, and erectile dysfunction. By virtue of our experience and skill, we are able to offer an effective treatment option for nearly every man who desires an effective treatment for any problem that affects the penis.  We offer medical and surgical treatment for men’s sexual problems.

We Treat Some of the Most Complex Men’s Health Problems:

Schedule an Appointment with Dr. Shteynshlyuger:

Call/text today: 1-646-663-5515 or make an appointment online

Dr. Shteynshlyuger is a fellowship-trained, board-certified urologist with expertise in the evaluation and treatment of prostate problems, including elevated PSA, enlarged prostate, and prostate cancer.  He also treats side effects of prostate treatment, including sexual, urinary, and erection problems in men.  He uses modern, effective, and proven treatment methods.  We offer prostate biopsy and treatment of localized and metastatic prostate cancer with surgery, immunotherapy, radiation therapy, and chemotherapy.  We also offer inflatable penile implant, shockwave therapy for ED, and treatment for Peyronie’s disease. We perform procedures such as hydrogel insertion prior to radiation therapy (SpaceOAR), prostate enucleation for enlarged prostate, and the Urolift procedure.  

He has successfully treated hundreds of men with a nodular prostate, elevated PSA, prostate cancer, and erection problems.

He is highly recommended by top primary care physicians in the New York area. If you or someone you know has been experiencing urological symptoms, make an appointment to take advantage of Dr. Shteynshlyuger’s expert advice. Please feel free to contact us with any questions.


If you have any questions, to schedule a consultation, please contact us or call/text: 1-646-663-5515.

We have excellent reviews from patients and their partners.  Information for out-of-state and international patients.  Find out our office hours or directions to our office. 

We offer affordable appointment prices with or without insurance.  Same-day virtual video appointments and in-person appointments are available.

This post is also available in: Spanish Russian